So it turns out I needed a week off from soaps. And last week was it. So I’m a week behind on GH and two weeks behind on Days, but I’m now soap-refreshed again.
I reach this conclusion because while standing in the shower this morning my mind started drifting in a soapy direction without prompting. Other than the prompting of actually using soap, of course.
What occurred to me during this diversion was this question: where are the marriages?
Perhaps the biggest of all soap traditions is that a couple battles through trials and tribulations to finally get together and get married. Usually followed rapidly by a child and equally rapidly by a divorce. And often a second marriage.
I am not saying that that’s necessarily a good thing, especially when it results in multiple marriages for the same couple in a manner that fast comes to look like (a) laziness; (b) a series of ratings stunts; or (c) all of the above.
It becomes ridiculous pretty quickly. How many times were All My Children’s Tad and Dixie married? Three between 1989 and 2002. And adult children with bad hair notwithstanding, realistically Dixie isn’t even 40 yet six years after the last divorce (and she’s less likely to be dead-by-pancakes by the minute).
With the annoying exception of the four times married Carly and Sonny, General Hospital has generally steered away from the multiple same couple marriage roundabout over the years. But even with that rider, it seems unusual to look around the show’s whole gigantic canvas and find that there are currently only two married couples in Port Charles: Jax and Carly and the currently separated Luke and Tracy.
I don’t think I’m missing anyone am I?
Doesn’t that seem bizarre? Perhaps it’s having two of the most married people in town in Jax (5 marriage plus 1 with pseudo-wife Brenda) and Carly (7 marriages) married to each other that’s keeping the marriage rate down.
I don’t necessarily think it’s a problem, but I find it interesting that with all the other soap traditions GH has eschewed in recent years (romance, heroes who are actually heroes, respecting its primarily female audience), one of them seems to be marriage.
Over at Days this issue is more about just dodging clarifying certain marital relationships. Steve and Kayla, for example. They act and talk as if they are married but there’s no way they can be, is there? He died over 15 years ago in a manner that was questioned by no one but the privy-to-the-coffin-swap audience, but which must have had a death certificate attached. Therefore, no longer married. And yet the writers have not taken the opportunity to address this with a third wedding for the super couple. One can only ask whether that will happen post-Ava. Similar issues apply to John and Marlena (though they’ve been married enough already).
Beyond that, Days is brimming with actually married couples in comparison to GH: Bo and Hope, Maggie and the soon to no longer be off-screen Mickey (I smell a divorce coming on), the mostly off-screen Doug and Julie, the currently-of-convenience EJ and Sami, the sailing away Shawn and Belle (if they hadn’t sailed, their marriage would have), technically Chloe and the off-screen Brady, and Lexie and Abe.
In fact Days has a really good mix of the type of marriages I would hope for in watching a soap. The young and doomed to several more goes around. The older solid, earned their long term happiness marriages. The overcome their trials and tribulations and now having fun middle-aged marriages. The sparky marriage of convenience.
So why is GH so different right now? Is it just an anomaly? An outcome of killing off marriage maniac Courtney? Or is it a particular decision? GH has always been wary about marrying off a few characters in particular. Brenda, who got so close but never actually had a genuine marriage in her whole run on the show – her annulled marriage of really poor disguise with Jason was her only valid ceremony. Jason himself. He lived with Robin for some time, Sam for longer, but the only person other than Brenda that he actually married was Courtney and that was retconned as invalid pretty damn quickly. Is there another show on which someone like Robin Scorpio, who has been on the show since age 7 and had three major loves, would have never been engaged, let alone married?
But even with that heritage, the current dearth of marriages in Port Charles does seem to stick out. And doesn’t seem likely to change in the near future. Can you honestly see weddings in the immediate future of Sonny and Kate, Jason and Elizabeth, Robin and Patrick, or Lucky and Sam? I can’t. Can you see the ground laid for a sparkling marriage of convenience turning to something more like Alexis’s marriages to Jax and then Ric? I can’t. Can you see any of our young ingénues entering into an ill-fated first union? They’re too busy keeping Lulu available for everyone, it doesn’t seem like Maxie’s style, and they killed everyone else off, so I can’t see it there either.
As I said, I don’t necessarily think that this is a bad thing, but I do wonder how this state of affairs (and affairs, and lack of affairs) has come about.
Does the lack of marriages mean that the show values them more? That is, fewer couples wind up getting married so they really have to earn their marriages, rather than weddings at the drop of the hat followed by divorces with equal speed and second weddings that then have less value. It might well be, especially looking at the recent exceptions that prove the rule, Sonny and Carly’s multiple and increasingly stupid marriages, and Lucky and Elizabeth’s divorce followed by hugely misguided (for the writers and the characters) second marriage and ultra-rapid divorce. But the flipside is that a lot of couples miss out on that ultimate, in traditional soap terms, pay-off. Again, Brenda never actually married either of the other axis’ of the Best Soap Triangle Ever, and Alexis may have married both Jax and Ric, but she never actually married Ned.
On the Days side, a super couple must get married at least twice and then nothing will ultimately put them asunder. To the point, until the reinvention of Bo and Hope last year, of utter predictability and boredom.
Until that recent upsurge with Days ceasing to write in a marriage=death manner – perhaps Hogan Sheffer’s best legacy – I would have automatically come down on the GH side of the equation, but now I’m not so sure. On any number of levels I would certainly like to see GH try and write a long term marriage which is interesting but largely happy in the manner of Bo and Hope. Though I just don’t see where that’s going to come from right now in Port Charles given there are currently only two possible candidates and one of them features the most married characters in town and the other features characters in their 60s so it's surprisingly that they’re written for at all.